Family:
Marriage:
Children:
- Richard
- Roger
Marriage:
Children:
- Roger Count Of St. Pol Death: 13 Jun 1067
- Engelbert
- Peter Count Of Arlo
Bibliography
Sources for birth and parent Information
- parents:
- [Ref: Moriarty Plantagenet p277],
- note:
- very doubtful [Ref: Stewart Baldwin SGM 10/9/2002-173612]
Sources with Information about marriage to Ada De Beaumont
- date:
- abt 1008/10 [Ref: Moriarty Plantagenet p277],
- child:
- [Ref: Moriarty Plantagenet p277]
Sources with Information about marriage to Odale
- date:
- second marriage of Eudes [Ref: Moriarty Plantagenet p277],
- child:
- [Ref: Moriarty Plantagenet p277]
Research Notes:
Count of Cambria [Ref: Moriarty Plantagenet p277]
The question of count Eudes of Cambrai has been mentioned in this newsgroup
before. The basic claim, from Moriarty's manuscript of Plantagenet Ancestry,
stated to be based on a manuscript study by Friedrich von Stauffenberg, gives
the following basic claimed table
Arnulf II Thibaud
count of seigneur of
Flanders Bois Ferrand
____________|____________________ |
| | | |
Baldwin IV Mathilda | |
count of m. Guibert | |
Flanders sgr. of Beaumont | |
|________ | |
| | |
Adela-m-Eudes-m-Adela
| |
2 sons Counts of
St. Pol and
Brienne
I had commented earlier on my failure to find anything backing up the
above, but a closer look has now left me with much suspicion.
The account (evidently based on notes that Moriarty took from Stauffenberg)
states that the records of St. Pierre de Cambrai (no more specific citation)
contain a remembrance of count Odo/Eudes, son of count Arnulf and Susanna
"lately queen of France" (i.e., Arnulf's wife who later married the king of
France) providing for prayers for the souls of his father Arnulf, mother
Susanna, and sister Mathilda, widow of Guilbert de Beaumont.
It then goes on to say that Eudes created a stir by marrying his own niece
Adela, daughter of Mathilda ca. 1009/10, was anathematized by Pope Benedict
IX, and that a letter from Baldwin IV to the pope in 1012 regarding the matter
is in Migne PL vol. 116 or 117 (with the possibility mentioned in earlier
postings that this should be read as 126-7 or 136-7, although the second
digits do not look like any other 2's or 3's on the same page).
In describing the second marriage of Eudes, it states that Thibuad sgr. of
Bois Ferrand is called "Thibaud de Louvain" by Alberic de Trois Fontaines,
Orderic Vitalis, and William of Juminges.
So what is suspicious? Many things:
1. The pope in 1012 was Benedict VIII, not Benedict IX.
2. I checked volumes 116-7, 126-7, 136-7 of PL PLUS all of the volumes that
actually have letter of popes Benedict VIII or IX, without finding the alleged
letter. (Of course, the lack of good indexes here makes this result
inconclusive.)
3. I checked Alberic de Trois Fontaines, Orderic Vitalis, and William of
Juminges without finding any reference to the Thibaud of Louvain in question
(or to Thibaud of Bois Ferrand, or to Eudes).
4. With the exception of a couple of places clearly using Moriarty as a
source, no account of the counts of Flanders that I have seen (Vanderkindere,
ES, Brandenburg, etc.) mentions a son of Arnulf II named Eudes.
5. The marriage of an uncle and niece would have been so extraordinarily
rare in this setting that one would think that it would attract much attention
in the literature, yet I have seen the claim nowhere else.
6. I have seen no source that proves that "count Eudes of Cambrai" ever
even existed, let alone providing any parentage for him (again excepting items
using Moriarty as a source).
It seems to me that this all adds up to a very suspicious picture,
especially as it includes several apparently nonexistent citations. I lean
toward the tentative conclusion that the Stauffenberg paper on which Moriarty
relied was a fraud, and that much of the claim is a fabrication. I would guess
that Moriarty never got around to checking the citations, as this does come
from his notes, and is not what he was presenting as a finished product. [Ref:
Stewart Baldwin SGM 10/9/2002-173612]
falsely attributed son (existence unlikely, evidently a fabrication)
Eudes count of Cambrai, m(1) Adele de Beaumont, his niece, m(2) Adele de
Bois-Ferrand (existance of both spouses also doubtful) [Ref: HenryII arnul000
11/25/2007]
Pedigree of Eudes Count Of Cambria
/-----
Lyderic Count Of Harlebec
/-----
Engelram Count Of Harlebec
/-----
Odoacre Count Of Harlebec
| \-----
Friderada
/-----
Baldwin I Bras De Fer Count Of Flanders
/-----
Baldwin II The Bald Count Of Flanders
| | /-----
Charlemagne King Of France
| | /-----
Louis I The Fair Emperor Of The West
| | | \-----
Hildegarde Of Swabia, Countess Of Vinzgau
| | /-----
Charles II The Bald King Of Franks, Emperor
| | | | /-----
Guelph Count Of Andech And Bavaria
| | | \-----
Judith Of Bavaria
| | | \-----
Edith (Heilwig) Of Saxony, Abbess Of Chelles
| \-----
Judith
| | /-----
Hadrian Lord In The Worms
| | /-----
Eudes Count Of Orleans
| | | \-----
Waldast
| \-----
Ermentrude Of Orleans
| | /-----
Leuthard Count Of Fezenac
| \-----
Engeltrude
| \-----
Grimihild
/-----
Arnold I The Old Count Of Flanders
| | /-----
Eahlmund King of Kent
| | /-----
Egbert The Great King Of England
| | | \-----
(Unk Dau)
| | /-----
Ethelwolf King Of England
| | | \-----
Raedburh
| | /-----
Alfred The Great King Of England
| | | | /-----
Oslac Great Butler Of England
| | | \-----
Osburh
| \-----
Alfthryth Of England
| | /-----
Aethelred Earl Of Mercia
| \-----
Ealhswith
| | /-----
Witglaff King Of Mercia
| | /-----
Wigmund
| \-----
Eadburgh Of Mercia
/-----
Baldwin III Count Of Flanders
| | /-----
Karlman (Pepin) King Of Italy And Bavaria
| | /-----
Bernard King Of Italy
| | | \-----
Therres
| | /-----
Pepin Count Of Senlis, Peronne, & St. Quentin
| | | | /-----
Caribert
| | | \-----
Cunigunde
| | /-----
Herbert I Count Of Vermandois
| | | | /-----
Niebelung III Count Of Burgundy
| | | | /-----
Theoderic Count Of Vermandois
| | | \-----
(Unk Dau) Of Vermandois
| | /-----
Herbert II Count Of Vermandois
| | | | /-----
Guerra I Count Of Morvois
| | | \-----
Beatrice Of Morvois
| | | \-----
Eve Of Roussillon
| \-----
Alix De Vermandois
| | /-----
Rupert II Count In Wormgau
| | /-----
Guiguin Rupert III Count In Wormgau
| | | \-----
Theoderata
| | /-----
Rupert IV The Strong Count Of Tours
| | | | /-----
Hadrian Lord In The Worms
| | | \-----
Wialdruth
| | | \-----
Waldast
| | /-----
Robert I King Of France
| | | | /-----
Luitfriede II Count Of Alsace
| | | | /-----
Hugh le Mefiant Count Of Tours
| | | | | \-----
Hiltrude
| | | \-----
Aelis Of Tours And Alsace
| | | \-----
Ava
| \-----
Hildebrante/Liegarde/Adela
| \-----
Aelis
/-----
Arnold II The Young Count Of Flanders
| | /-----
Billung Count In Saxony
| | /-----
Hermann Billung Duke Of Saxony
| | | \-----
Fraderuna
| \-----
Matilda Of Saxony
| \-----
Hildegarde Of Westerbourg
Eudes Count Of Cambria
| /-----
Amadeus Count In Payn De Langres
| /-----
Anchier Count Of Orcheret, Margrave Of Ivrea
| /-----
Adalbert The Rich Margrave Of Ivrea
| /-----
Berengar II King Of Italy
| | | /-----
Hunroch Count of Ternois
| | | /-----
Eberhard Margrave Of Friuli
| | | | | /-----
Girard Count Of Paris
| | | | | /-----
Begue Count Of Paris
| | | | | | \-----
Rotrude
| | | | \-----
Engeltron Of Paris
| | | | | /-----
Louis I The Fair Emperor Of The West
| | | | \-----
Aupals
| | | /-----
Berengar I King Of Italy
| | | | | /-----
Pepin The Short King Of The Franks
| | | | | /-----
Charlemagne King Of France
| | | | | | \-----
Bertha Of Laon, Countess Of Laon
| | | | | /-----
Louis I The Fair Emperor Of The West
| | | | | | | /-----
Gerold I Count In The Anglachau
| | | | | | \-----
Hildegarde Of Swabia, Countess Of Vinzgau
| | | | | | \-----
Emma
| | | | \-----
Gisele
| | | | | /-----
Ruthardus Duke Of Bavaria
| | | | | /-----
Guelph Count Of Andech And Bavaria
| | | | \-----
Judith Of Bavaria
| | | | | /-----
(Unk) Saxon
| | | | \-----
Edith (Heilwig) Of Saxony, Abbess Of Chelles
| | \-----
Gisele Of Friuli
| | | /-----
Maurin PFALZGRAF
| | | /-----
Suppo Margrave Of Spoleto
| | \-----
Bertila Of Spoleto
| | | /-----
Wilfred Count
| | \-----
Berta
\-----
Rosela Of Italy
| /-----
Boso I Count Of Arles And Tuscany
| /-----
Boso II Count Of Arles And Tuscany
| /-----
Boso III The Old Count Of Arles And Tuscany
| /-----
Herbert Marquis Of Transjurian Burgundy
| /-----
Theobald Count Of Aries
| /-----
Boso Count Of Aries
| | | /-----
Charlemagne King Of France
| | | /-----
Louis I The Fair Emperor Of The West
| | | | \-----
Hildegarde Of Swabia, Countess Of Vinzgau
| | | /-----
Lothair I King Of Italy, Emperor Of The West
| | | | | /-----
Ingerman Count Of Hasbaye
| | | | \-----
Ermengarde Of Haspengau
| | | /-----
Lothair II The Saxon King Of Lorraine
| | | | | /-----
Luitfriede II Count Of Alsace
| | | | | /-----
Hugh le Mefiant Count Of Tours
| | | | | | \-----
Hiltrude
| | | | \-----
Ermengarde Of Tours
| | | | \-----
Ava
| | \-----
Bertha Of Lorraine
| | \-----
Waldrada
\-----
Willa Of Aries
| /-----
Ruthardus Duke Of Bavaria
| /-----
Guelph Count Of Andech And Bavaria
| /-----
Conrad I Of Burgandy, Count Of Auxerra
| | | /-----
(Unk) Saxon
| | \-----
Edith (Heilwig) Of Saxony, Abbess Of Chelles
| /-----
Conrad II Duke Of Transjurand Burgandy
| | | /-----
Luitfriede II Count Of Alsace
| | | /-----
Hugh le Mefiant Count Of Tours
| | | | \-----
Hiltrude
| | \-----
Aelis Of Tours And Alsace
| | \-----
Ava
| /-----
Rudolph I King Of Upper Burgundy
| | \-----
Walrada
\-----
Willa Of Tuscany
| /-----
Richard Count Of Rouen
| /-----
Richard Count Of Amiens
| /-----
Budwine Count Of Metz
| /-----
Boso Of Vienne, King Of Provence
| | | /-----
Boso II Count Of Arles And Tuscany
| | | /-----
Boso III The Old Count Of Arles And Tuscany
| | \-----
Richilda
\-----
Wille
Descendants of Eudes Count Of Cambria
2nd generation
3rd generation
4th generation
5th generation